Hilary's book blog experiment

I read too much and too fast. I write too little and too slowly. This might help both problems. Inspired by Sara Nelson's So Many Books, So Little Time: A Year of Passionate Reading and a longstanding desire to track what I read.

January 05, 2004

Master and Commander by Patrick O'Brien, 1970.

Brian Gafney, a library patron, saw the movie and asked me to get the book through interlibrary loan. I'd just seen the movie too so I borrowed it when he was done with it, and we'll get the next one too. (I just found a paperback copy in my collection...) Begun with great enjoyment but shrank on me a little. Russell Crowe's portrayal of Jack Aubrey impresses me more in retrospect having read the book--Paul Bettany was good as Stephen Maturin, but not quite the Maturin of the book (who is physically different anyway, described as small and dark).

Both the accusations of "Tom Clancy on the high seas" and the hyperbole of "great literature" seem off the mark. The depth of characterization too well-done for the former, the tinge of "look how much research I've done!" too striking for the latter. I was also left with an impression of disjointedness overall.

Brian said this doesn't hold a candle to C.S. Forester, whom I don't recall ever reading. I found Commodore Hornblower in my collection, so I'll put that in the "read pretty soon" pile. I remember enjoying Mr. Midshipman Easy (Marryat), and the Swallows and Amazons series (Ransom) were favorites at one time, but I'm not that familair with sea stories as a genre.

3 Comments:

  • At 11/07/2008 08:27:00 AM, Blogger Bob said…

    Hi Hilary,

    I stumbled across your comments on Patrick O'Brien. You might be interested to know that the original screenplay for "Master and Commander" closely followed the first volume of O'Brien's Aubrey-Maturin series. Then it was scrapped in favor of a composite story taken from several of the books.

    On this subject, I would listen to no ones's advice but your own. It's like fine wine; you will either appreciate it or you won't.

    If you like history - but you wish it was more fun to read, here's a recommendation that won't disappoint, "Defying Empire: Trading with the Enemy in Colonial New York"

    http://yalepress.yale.edu/yupbooks/book.asp?isbn=9780300118407

    It reads more like a novel than a history book, and what you will learn about our Founding Fathers may shock you. Check it out.

    Have fun, and start reading Patrick O'Brien -- but no skimming.

     
  • At 11/07/2008 08:27:00 AM, Blogger Bob said…

    Hi Hilary,

    I stumbled across your comments on Patrick O'Brien. You might be interested to know that the original screenplay for "Master and Commander" closely followed the first volume of O'Brien's Aubrey-Maturin series. Then it was scrapped in favor of a composite story taken from several of the books.

    On this subject, I would listen to no ones's advice but your own. It's like fine wine; you will either appreciate it or you won't.

    If you like history - but you wish it was more fun to read, here's a recommendation that won't disappoint, "Defying Empire: Trading with the Enemy in Colonial New York"

    http://yalepress.yale.edu/yupbooks/book.asp?isbn=9780300118407

    It reads more like a novel than a history book, and what you will learn about our Founding Fathers may shock you. Check it out.

    Have fun, and start reading Patrick O'Brien -- but no skimming.

     
  • At 12/06/2008 04:31:00 PM, Blogger Mike said…

    Patrick O'Brien fans will really like "Defying Empire: Trading with the Enemy in Colonial New York," a new book featuring the Royal Navy in American waters during the late colonial period. It has one advantage over those fabulous Aubrey-Maturin novels, it's all true. http://defyingempire.com/

     

Post a Comment

<< Home