January 2020 books read

  • The Genius of Birds – Jennifer Ackerman, 2016
  • The Magician’s Book: A Skeptic’s Adventures in Narnia – Laura Miller, 2008. The rare book where my reaction was “I wish I had written this,” because Miller explores so much of what pulls me to re-read these books. I didn’t pull quotes but there’s more I want to explore on a second read. Someday!
  • Milkman – Anna Burns, 2018
  • Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing – Robert Caro, 2019 – Couldn’t put it down! I actually haven’t read any of Caro’s biographies but now I want to. My favorite bits were these two heart-warming incidents:

I was still in the first year of research [on The Power Broker] when friends and acquaintances began to ask if I was “still doing that book.” Later I would be asked, “How long have you been working on it now?” When I said three years, or four, or five, they would quickly disguise their look of incredulity, but not quickly enough to keep me from seeing it. I came to dread that question.

Then one day, I looked up and James Flexner was standing over me. The expression on his face was friendly, but after he had asked what I was writing about, the next question was the question I had come to dread: “How long have you been working on it?” This time, however, when I replied, “Five years,” the response was not an incredulous stare.
“Oh,” Jim Flexner said, “that’s not so long. I’ve been working on my Washington for nine years.”
I could have jumped up and kissed him, whiskers and all—as, the next day, I could have jumped up and kissed Joe Lash, big beard and all, when he asked me the same question, and, after hearing my answer, said in his quiet way, “Eleanor and Franklin took me seven years.” In a couple of sentences, these two men—idols of mine—had wiped away five years of doubt.

Lynn [Nesbit] had read my manuscript, and said, “I’d like to represent you, but you have to tell me something first. Why do you look so worried?”
I didn’t know I looked worried. But of course I was. I told her, “I’m worried that I won’t have enough money to finish the book.” My editor had left me feeling that few people would read a book on Robert Moses, and that therefore no publisher would give me the money I needed to finish it.
She asked how much money I was talking about. I told her I needed enough so I could spend two more years on the book. I thought it would take me two years. I don’t remember the exact amount I specified, but I know it was not that large. And all of a sudden there were other sentences that I’ll never forget. She said, “Is that what you’re worried about? Then you can stop worrying right now. I can get you that by just picking up the phone. Everybody in New York knows about this book.”
Then she said, “You can stop worrying about money. But I’ve read this manuscript. What you care about is writing. My job is to find you an editor you can work with for the rest of your life.”

  • Don Quixote (El ingenioso caballero don Quijote de la Mancha) – Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra, 1615 (tr Edith Grossman, 2005) – quotes pulled, TBD

The Genius of Birds – Jennifer Ackerman, 2016

Wonderful read for the Nature and Environment book group. The language is sometimes a little precious: hippocampus described as “this whiff of tissue”; “a glister of goldfinches”; “a twitch of birders.”

I looked up:

  • gökotta – Swedish tradition of getting up early to hear the first birdsong
  • kagu (Rhynochetos jubatus) – rare flightless New Caledonian bird
  • pigeons are better at the Monty Hall problem than humans
  • Cuba uses pigeons to transmit election results from remote mountainous areas
  • “in each of a bird’s cone cells is a drop of colored oil that enhances its ability to detect differences between similar colors”
  • I was very surprised to hear that house sparrow populations are declining around the world. You wouldn’t know it around here – they thrive!

Short quotes / facts:

  • “sexy” syllable: “when a male bird uses his syrinx to sing with two different voices at once”
  • A pet monk parakeet “obligingly sat on my shoulder and periodically leaned in to my ear to say, ‘Whisper, whisper, whisper.'”
  • “chickadees use their calls like language, complete with syntax that can generate an open-ended number of unique call types” (for example, the number of “dees” indicates the size of an approaching predator – more for smaller, hence more dangerous, predators)
  • “A frigate bird with a seven-foot wingspan has a skeleton that weighs less than its feathers”
  • mockingbird imitating a canary but not able to deliver the notes as rapidly “clusters the notes and pauses to breathe while still maintaining identical song length”; they regularly imitate as many as 200 different songs
  • Quote from the New Yorker so most likely too good to be true: “after weeks of silence, the first words uttered by a Westchester parakeet were, ‘Talk, damn you, talk!’”
  • Bowerbirds take seven years to mature, which correlates with their intelligence (learned a lot about them in Evolution of Beauty); females evaluate males in a way “very similar to a search for job candidates” (brief visit, then longer for the finalists)
  • white-crowned sparrow flock: “each a single feathered ounce of fortitude”
  • “Twilight is a rich source of information for navigating animals of all types. It’s the only period in the day when birds and other animals can combine light-polarization patterns, stars, and magnetic cues.”
  • Complexity of mapping/relating odors could have driven the ability to remember relationships between unrelated elements: “for example, the scent of a certain mineral or tree and the direction toward home”
  • In some cities, sparrows use cigarette butts in their nests for their ability to repel parasites
  • Quoting Richard F. Johnston: “Everything that is is adaptive.”
  • “A new study … suggests that, genetically speaking, the turkey is closer to its dinosaur ancestors than any other bird is; its chromosomes have undergone fewer changes than other birds since the days of feathered dinosaurs.”
  • Interesting behaviors: crows and others dunking food, skuas stealing milk from lactating seals

Longer quotes

Newborn chicks spatially “map” numbers from left to right, as most humans do (left means less; right means more). This suggests that birds share with us a left-to-right orientation system—a cognitive strategy that underlies our human capacity for higher mathematics. Baby birds can also understand proportion and can learn to choose a target from an array of objects on the basis of its ordinal position (third, eighth, ninth). They can do simple arithmetic, as well, such as addition and subtraction.

Like the black-billed cuckoo a friend saw perched just above a nest of tent caterpillars: The cuckoo waited as the caterpillars climbed out of the nest to scale the tree, then plucked them off one at a time, like sushi from a conveyor belt.

Closely-related birds, the Bajan bullfinch and the black-faced grassquit:

“These two birds are virtual genetic twins with the same ancestor, having diverged probably only a couple of million years ago,” Lefebvre explains. “Both live in the same environment. Both are territorial and share the same social system.” The only difference is that the bullfinch is clever, fearless, and opportunistic; and the grassquit, skittish, deeply conservative, and afraid of nearly everything. … [A grad student] has measured the speed at which the two species will feed from an open cup of seed. The bullfinches find the novel food source in about five seconds, she says. It takes the grassquits five days. “A yogurt top filled with seeds is just too odd for them.”

Quote by naturalist Edmond Selous about flocking birds:

“They circle; now dense like a polished roof, now disseminated like the meshes of some vast all-heaven-sweeping net, now darkening, now flashing out a million rays of light . . . a madness in the sky,” he wrote. “They must think collectively, all at the same time, or at least in streaks or patches—a square yard or so of an idea, a flash out of so many brains.”

An award for nest-building brilliance should go to the long-tailed tit, a common relative of the chickadee that lives in Europe and Asia. Its nest is a flexible bag composed of small-leaved mosses that form hooks, which are woven together with the silk loops of fluffy spider egg cocoons to create a kind of “Velcro.” The little birds work to line the inside of the bag with thousands of small insulating feathers and cover the outside with thousands of small lichen flakes for camouflage, creating a structure made of roughly six thousand separate pieces.

Is there something special in the cognitive toolkits of house sparrows and their like—pigeons, turtledoves, and other so-called synanthropes drawn to settle near humans—a set of mental skills that allows them to thrive in a place no matter how altered or degraded it may be?

Most vertebrates are either fearful of strange objects or indifferent to them. But newfangledness of most kinds doesn’t seem to faze a house sparrow. When Lynn Martin of the University of South Florida, Tampa, tested the sparrow’s tolerance for novel objects such as a rubber ball and a toy plastic lizard by placing them near seed-filled feeding cups, he discovered a surprise. The house sparrows were not only unperturbed by the strange objects, they actually seemed drawn to them—happier to approach the seed-filled dishes when ball or lizard was present. Martin noted that this was the first record of a novel object actually being attractive to a vertebrate (apart from man).

If you’re going to invade a new place, a love of novelty helps.

So does a fondness for hanging out in groups.

But later Daniel Sol explains in the case of Carib grackles:

“Bolder individuals tend to explore more quickly but more superficially, … the slower explorers gain better information and use this to act with more flexibility.”

December 2019 books read

  • Finished The Chronicles of Narnia
  • A Long Way Down – Nick Hornby, 2005 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Booklife: Strategies and Survival Tips for the 21st-Century Writer – Jeff VanderMeer, 2007. Not your typical writing book at all. It’s a little outdated in some respects, but covers so many aspects of publication and career that it’s still full of valuable and interesting information.
  • Drawdown: The Most Comprehensive Plan Ever Proposed to Reverse Global Warming – Paul Hawken (ed.), 2017 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • The Black Envelope (Mr. Pinkerton Again!) – David Frome, 1937 – Jonathan loves silly/cozy mysteries and recommended this one as a good representative of the Mr. Pinkerton series. Not bad, not great.
  • A Death in the Family – James Agee, 1956 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • The Secret Commonwealth – Philip Pullman, 2019. I enjoyed it very much but read it quickly. I’ll re-read the whole Book of Dust trilogy after the 3rd one comes out (Wikipedia says Pullman hasn’t even started it, yikes) and have a better sense then of the whole.
  • Death From a Top Hat – Clayton Rawson, 1938 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Measure for Murder – Clifford Witting, 1941. Another mystery Jonathan was trying out, and because it was set in the theater world and was in a series called Fifty Classics of Crime Fiction, 1900-1950 (I love best-of lists!) it was my 3rd for the month—super-unusual for me, and I’m probably off the mystery train for a while. I just picked up two interesting terms: “compactum,” a dresser (still in use in South Africa), and “Tansad” used to mean a working stool (the company name was Tan-Sad but this article says it comes from “tansad,” a French word meaning pillion seat).

Notable quote from a magazine article, “The Sanctuary” by Elif Batuman (New Yorker, Dec 19-26, 2011):

I thought about the power of the sacred: originating, if the archeologists are to be believed, in the most material expediencies of the body—how and what to eat—it overtakes the soul, making Neolithic man build Göbekli Tepe and making him bury it, sweeping through the millennia, generating monuments, strivings, vast inner landscapes. I thought about history, and the riddle of the Sphinx: what goes on four legs in the morning, on two legs at noon, and on three legs in the evening? Some people say that history is progress: isn’t this just a reflection of how we’re born, tiny, weak, and speechless, and then go on to build cathedrals and fly to the moon? When others say that history is a decline from a golden age, isn’t this because youth is so brief and we regret it for so long?

Year in review

I got almost all the books I read into Goodreads this year (might have missed a few), which helpfully counts them and tells me I read 33,705 pages (!) across 104 books. The “most popular” book was Huckleberry Finn, supposedly read by 1.2 million people this year, but only 5 also read The Black Envelope (still more than I would have expected!)

However, I am tremendously underwater with my retrospective posts of quotes pulled from book group books. I have made progress with the actual pulling—backlog under 10 I think—but draft posts etc. has got to be closer to 75. It’s OK if I never finish the actual posts as long as I grab the quotes, since this blog is really just for me anyway…

The Chronicles of Narnia – C. S. Lewis, 1950 – 1956

I was just going to add notes to the listings in the monthly round-up (November and December 2019), but they started getting long! Looks like I last re-read these 18 months ago, which is probably a typical interval for me over my lifetime as I love them so much. For such short books it’s amazing how they still elicit new reactions and thoughts

  • The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, 1950. I craved making Mr. Tumnus’ tea—I thought the sugar-topped cake would be a pound cake, but most of the recipes dreamed up online are more of a fruit cake. I might make the cinnamon tea cake here and dig into some of those other posts!
  • Prince Caspian, 1951
  • The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, 1952
  • The Silver Chair, 1953. This time around I noticed how the suspense often resolves quickly, not the typical ratcheting-up, things-get-worse-and-worse techniques I associate with modern fiction (even for children). Near the end, this little drama happens in one paragraph: “The tide was running up the valley like a mill-race, and if it had come to swimming, the horses could hardly have won over. But it was still only a foot or two deep, and though it swished terribly round the horses’ legs, they reached the far side in safety.” And earlier, when the witch-snake almost overpowers Rilian, similarly it’s wrapped up in one page. The suspense still works but it’s not gory or drawn out. It reminded me of Lucy resisting the temptation to cast the “become the most beautiful” spell in Voyage of the Dawn Treader. In the world of Narnia our protagonists encounter perils and make wrong choices without the worst quite happening. It makes sense that Lewis wrote Perelandra, an Eve story with a happy ending.
  • The Horse and His Boy, 1954. Calormen is clearly larger and more populous than Narnia. It took a long time for the Narnia-centrism (beyond the general racism) to jump out to me, partly I suppose because Narnia is cognate to England and that cultural viewpoint is the water I’ve been bathed in since childhood. On the mostly accurate charges of sexism and racism, Devin Brown tries to marshall a defense of Lewis, but it goes deeper than he admits. [note from future (Jan 2020) reading: Laura Miller’s The Magician’s Book nails it]
  • The Magician’s Nephew, 1955. Same thought writ large: this is the creation story of “Narnia” (ie this whole world and possibly universe), with Aslan singing the very mountains into existence—but what about all the other lands/nations we’ve encountered: Archenland, Calormen, the Lone Islands, even Bism deep in the earth…?
  • The Last Battle, 1956. Again the end of Narnia-the-world is centered on Narnia-the-tiny-country. But on the good side, I noticed afresh how important this book was to me in shaping my ability to identify and avoid/deflect a certain kind of person. The monkey Shift manipulates his friend Puzzle the donkey by playing the martyr, telling him he’s doing things “for your sake,” asserting his special ability to do or know certain things. My impression is that Shift must be modeled on Mrs. Moore (a very interesting aspect of Lewis’ life, although there’s plenty of controversy about her character), but I only find references to her inspiring the “all-I-want” woman in The Screwtape Letters. Lucy defends Puzzle against those who blame him for going along with Shift (bringing disaster), but the text is ambiguous enough that I took away the need to develop and trust your instincts. Combined with the storyline of Emeth (the Calormen soldier who’s told that his sincerity in searching for truth meant that he was really a follower of Aslan rather than Tash), The Last Battle actually contributed to my religious skepticism/atheism.

Someday I want to write an essay about Narnia and Christianity—a topic that’s been explored in depth by many, but I’ve never seen my take fully represented. That will entail yet another re-read. I’m already looking forward to it!

November 2019 books read

  • The Parable of the Sower – Octavia Butler, 1993. Re-read, quotes TBD.
  • The Evolution of Beauty: How Darwin’s Forgotten Theory of Mate Choice Shapes the Animal World—And Us – Richard Prum, 2017. Quotes pulled, TBD.
  • Jonathan Livingston Seagull – Richard Bach, 1970. Re-read for the umpteenth time (it’s so short!), but my opinion of it drops a little each time.
  • Round the Bend – Nevil Shute, 1951. Umpteenth re-read (yes, I was needing comfort reading) but holds up still.
  • Homage to Catalonia – George Orwell, 1938 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Dancing at Lughnasa – Brian Friel, 1990 – For Irish Writers book group. Only one quote so not enough for a separate post: Gerry, who’s signed up to go fight in the Spanish Civil War (coincidental, having just read Homage to Catalonia), is asked why he’s going.
    Not so sure I know either. … And there’s bound to be something right about the cause, isn’t there? And it’s somewhere to go—isn’t it? Maybe that’s the important thing for a man: a named destination—democracy, Ballybeg, heaven. Women’s illusions aren’t so easily satisfied—they make better drifters.
  • The Countess Cathleen – W.B. Yeats, 1912 – also for Irish Writers, quotes pulled TB.
  • Manage Your Day-to-Day: Build Your Routine, Find Your Focus, and Sharpen Your Creative Mind – Jocelyn K. Glei, 2013 (99U series) – This was really good! Short chapters with nice graphic design.
  • The Circadian Code: Lose Weight, Supercharge Your Energy, and Transform Your Health from Morning to Midnight – Satchin Panda, 2018 – It seemed really good, but mostly because I already do time-restricted eating (Panda’s major recommendation) and it’s worked really well for me. So I was nodding along & patting myself on the back, which is not the most objective frame of mind. In general I’m super-suspicious of “this is The One Answer!” books, but clearly less so when it’s something I’ve already adopted…
  • My Boyfriend Barfed in My Handbag… and Other Things You Can’t Ask Martha – Jolie Kerr, 2014 – I read the whole thing but I’m not 100% sure why. I may have learned a few things but I mostly forgot them again (OK, I do want to try using ammonia) and the jokey tone was fun in small doses, annoying in large. I guess I kept expecting Captain Awkward or Ask A Manager level advice/entertainment, but that bar is unreasonably high.
  • Drunkard: A Hard-Drinking Life – Neil Steinberg, 2008 – Ah, I thought maybe I had read this already – yes, back in 2010. Why did I put pub year of 2009 – maybe it was the paperback?
  • Started Chronicles of Narnia

October 2019 books read

  • The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks – Rebecca Skloot, 2010 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • The Changeling King (Estranged #2) – Ethan M. Aldridge, 2019
  • The Path of Least Resistance: Learning to Become the Creative Force in Your Own Life – Robert Fritz, 1989 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Cat’s Eye – Margaret Atwood, 1998 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • A History of Loneliness, 2014 – John Boyne – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Spring Chicken: Stay Young Forever (or Die Trying) – Bill Griffin, 2015. Not bad… Griffin’s a little too into himself, but clearly explains why it’s all about exercise and purpose (ikigai is my biggest takeaway).
  • The Happiness Equation: Want Nothing + Do Anything = Have Everything – Neil Pasricha, 2015. Wait, he talks about ikigai as well… now I’m not sure which book I’m remembering it from. This was also not bad but evaporates from my memory like many self-help books. I did like very much that the main messages from each chapter are added to each time, so that the first ones get repeated – that really helps anchor them together. The full set is: be happy first; do it for you; remember the lottery; never retire; overvalue you; create space; just do it; be you; and don’t take advice, which is a great way to end a self-help book! But seriously, that list refreshes my memory enough to call this one above average.
  • Double Star – Robert Heinlein, 1956 – One of my favorite Heinleins, a taste I share with Connie Willis! I re-read it this time because of remembering “politics is the only sport for grownups.”

The Changeling King (Estranged #2) – Ethan M. Aldridge, 2019

The first book in the series blew me away. This one (the second in at least a trilogy?) I loved also, but of course it didn’t have quite the same element of surprise: I knew it would be great, and it is. The characters of the brothers-by-Fay-kidnapping continue to evolve, and the human parents and especially older sister Alexis get to take the stage as well. Alexis is who I would have wanted to be as a kid, and she gets to learn magic too! My favorite detail is the visual representation (drawings in speech bubbles) of the spells, and the ways that Alexis’ attempts go awry but are still useful. The view of Fay society and class struggle is great. I’m looking forward to the next volume, but it must take Aldridge a really long time to do the amazing art!

Average Rating:

4.2 rating based on 1,410 ratings (all editions)

ISBN-10: 0062653911
ISBN-13: 9780062653918
Goodreads: 41212409

Author(s): Publisher: Quill Tree Books
Published: 10/1/2019

Enter a world of faerie magic and epic adventure in this spellbinding sequel to Estranged—a rich fantasy graphic novel perfect for fans of Amulet.

After years of pretending to be human, the changeling Edmund Carter has assumed his rightful role as Cinder, king of the World Below. But not everyone at the royal palace is happy about his return.

Meanwhile, Ed is adjusting to human life in the World Above. His birth family treats him with a kindness he never knew growing up in the Fay court, but Ed misses the sense of purpose he had as a knight.

When a mysterious new threat emerges in the World Below, Cinder must call on Ed and their older sister, Alexis, for help. But nothing can prepare them for the family secret that awaits at the end of their perilous quest.

With over two hundred pages of gorgeous watercolor paintings, The Changeling King invites readers on an epic journey through a magical world—one they will not soon forget.
 

September 2019 books read

  • Pachinko – Min Jin Lee, 2017
  • The Sam Pig Story Book – Alison Uttley, 1965 – Comfort re-reading. Delightful stories with images that have lived in my mind since I first read them (around age 8-10?). The memory that drove me to pick it up this time was the story “Magic Water,” in which the pig family invite a Stranger (the rain personified) into their house, and he plays the fiddle for them:

He stood in the doorway and the rain poured from him in dancing cascades to the floor. He was dressed in black and and a long cloak hung from his shoulders. His hair was shining with water; the hands which held the great cloak around him were wet and rain fell from the long pointed finger tips. His bright eyes were like stars shining from the darkness. He carried a sheaf of long arrows, glittering like glass, fine as spun gold, thousands of them packed into the silver sheaf.

… He drew the bow across and the low wail of a coming storm filled the room. Then he changed his tune, and played airs so entrancing they brought pictures which seemed to float before their eyes, of rainbow days when light flashes after rain, or spring days when sun and rain strive for mastery.

  • T. Tembarom – Frances Hodgson Burnett, 1913 – CRR (comfort re-reading, of which there was lots this month, perhaps making up for last month. One Burnett always leads to several more!) – One of my very favorite FHBs, with great characters and a classic plot.
  • Little Lord Fauntleroy – Frances Hodgson Burnett, 1886 – CRR
  • An Artist of the Floating World – Kazuo Ishiguro, 1986 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are? – Frans de Waal, 2016 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Coach: Lessons on the Game of Life – Michael Lewis, 2005 – Picked this up at the LWV book sale so essentially free, but it’s going straight to next year’s donations. I normally love Michael Lewis, but is an OK essay turned into a gift/impulse purchase: skinny but $12.95 hardcover (in 2005!) with arty/sentimental BW photos of kids playing ball, fireworks, dogs, etc., some by Tabitha Soren (his wife). Interestingly, the title page verso has two copyright listings, one in each of their names.
  • Gulliver’s Travels – Jonathan Swift, 1726 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones – James Clear, 2018 – quite good but already mostly evaporated from my mind, like most self-help…
  • At Swim-Two-Birds -Flann O’Brien, 1939 – quotes pulled, TBD
  • Born Standing Up: A Comic’s Life – Steve Martin, 2007 – It was Trent Hamm who got me to read this, and wow, it is very good and interesting about the “how” and not just the “what” of Martin’s career.
  • The Simple Path to Wealth: Your Road Map to Financial Independence and a Rich, Free Life – J. L. Collins, 2016 – Everyone who tried Invested should read this instead—much better advice.
  • Earth Abides – George R. Stewart, 1949 – I love classic post-apocalyptic fiction and had never heard of this one until recently, but zillions of people recommend it. It’s excellent and I might re-read at some point as I do my other favorites.
  • The Ordinary Princess – M. M. Kaye, 1980 – I’ve owned a copy from a book sale for a long long time but finally got around to reading it—same impulse as comfort reading but not a re-read. Very good and satisfying!
  • A Little Princess – Frances Hodgson Burnett, 1905 – CRR for the umpteenth time!

August 2019 books read

  • Fall, or Dodge in Hell – Neal Stephenson, 2019. I love most Stephenson, but this was a snore. The VR Paradise Lost is an interesting idea but dragged out way way too long, and the elevated diction was clumsy.
  • The Liar’s Club – Mary Karr, 1995.
  • The Big Thirst: The Secret Life and Turbulent Future of Water – Charles Fishman, 2011.
  • The Grapes of Wrath – John Steinbeck, 1939
  • Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha – Roddy Doyle, 1993. Irish Writers book group selection. Most of us got kind of tired of the 10-year old’s voice and found it a slog, but we had a great discussion. We wondered why it won the Booker! It re-pointed me to Oliver Goldsmith’s “The Deserted Village“: ” And still they gazed, and still the wonder grew / That one small head could carry all he knew,” and I looked up Clarnico Iced Caramels.
  • Advice for Future Corpses (and Those Who Love Them): A Practical Perspective on Death and Dying – Sallie Tisdale, 2018. Wonderful and yes, very practical, if you’re ready to think about such things. A great companion to Being Mortal (Atul Gawande, 2014).
  • Old in Art School: A Memoir of Starting Over – Nell Irvin Painter, 2018. Enthralling and thought-provoking. I identified in many ways, as I’m slowly working my way towards a second bachelor’s in CS.
  • Estranged – Ethan M. Aldridge, 2018

Wow, no re-reads this month! Pretty unusual for me—but that’s one of the advantages of belonging to so many book groups, keeping me focused on new stuff (or purposeful re-reads, not just comfort reading).

Estranged – Ethan M. Aldridge, 2018

Fantasy is my favorite genre, but my bar for good fantasy is so high (and gets higher as I get older) that I very seldom find anything new to like, and only even try if the reviews are stellar. So when I say I loved loved loved this graphic novel, I mean it. Thank you Twitter, since it was a re-tweet of Aldridge’s amazing sketch of Lloyd Alexander’s Taran holding Hen Wen that led me to his work. Estranged is about a human child kidnapped by fairies and his changeling twin. They meet and team up, which seems like an obvious idea but which I’ve never seen done before, and Aldridge subtly shows the similarities and differences in their personalities and how their different environments shaped them. The art, pen-and-ink and watercolor, is gorgeous, but the writing is equally strong. There are great sibling and love relationships, themes of belonging and being yourself, a non-binary character who’s an enchanted living candle (another very cool idea!), strong female characters, a dragon in subway tunnels…. and hurray, a sequel is coming out in October!

Average Rating:

4.0 rating based on 3,629 ratings (all editions)

ISBN-10:
ISBN-13:
Goodreads: 31193404

Author(s): Publisher: HarperCollins
Published: 8/7/2018

Edmund and the Childe were swapped at birth. Now Edmund lives in secret as a changeling in the World Above, with fae powers that make him different from everyone else—even his unwitting parents and older sister, Alexis. The Childe lives among the fae in the World Below, where being human makes him an oddity at the royal palace, and where his only friend is a wax golem named Whick.

But when the cruel sorceress Hawthorne takes the throne, the Childe and Edmund realize that the fate of both worlds may be in their hands—even if they’re not sure which world they belong to.